Or maybe it should be illegal to have a court order that the privacy of millions of people should be infringed? I’m with OpenAI on this one, regardless of their less than pure reasons. You don’t get to wiretap all of the US population, and that’s essentially what they are doing here.
They are preserving evidence in a lawsuit. If you are concerned, you can try petitioning the court to keep your data private. I don't know how that would go.
You can use that same argument for wiretapping the US, because surely someone did something wrong. So we should just collect evidence on everyone on the off chance we need it.