HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | singleshot_'s commentslogin

How does the Fifth Amendment work in a civil context?

Is it appropriate to compare murder and running a red light given what you know about the civil implications of 5A?


It doesn't apply. The argument was that the red light violation was "quasi-criminal" and the judge agreed with that argument.

When you say, “these countries,” I imagine you include the United States, where politically connected youngsters like George W. Bush secured and then ignored jet interceptor training during the 1960s?

Be that as it may, I think we can agree that the USAF is not the same as the air forces of the Gulf countries.

Not everyone agrees that America is special. You haven't convincingly won a conflict in how long, so we're not really convinced your military is as exceptional as you like to say.

I'm not American

I would include the USA, with the caveat that in the US being sent to the military is often seen as a punishment for rich children where as in the Middle East being sent to the military can be an opportunity to build an independent power base for yourself or your family.

The USA has a volunteer military. Occasionally there are cases where the criminal court system might agree to dismiss a minor charge if the defendant enlists. But that doesn't happen to rich people, or those joining as commissioned officers (pilot track).

This is all true but I can’t see how it’s relevant to why I said.

Your amateur radio license is only active when:

Not a repeat; an error. How many people were in their seats, unbuckled?

Care to explain how a circuit court might come to hear an appeal out of a state court of general jurisdiction?

> they’re legally required to in the US

Obviously false, not even arguable


Same reason they cant quarter troops in your house: the law

Directing your attention to Coca-Cola

> can't wait to see 6 cylinder engines go the way of the v8.

You want to stuff an in-line six in every race car, buggy, and Jeep that you see, with a supercharger slapped on top? Why not just go with an LS?


> weren't on their deathbeds with covid claiming it was a hoax

Have you treated many patients with COVID? I’ve heard the opposite of your claim from those who have.


As the husband at the time of a military critical care nurse who worked local ED in a major US city and deployed to New York -- yes, there were absolutely people who denied they had COVID even as they were being intubated.

Most people tended to accept reality when their body started failing, but there were a non-zero number that refused to believe they were infected with coronavirus to the end.

Politicians and social media click farmers spouting lies do influence people, and not everyone starts with a basic understanding of biology and/or science.


People with first hand experience offering counterpoints like Dr Dan Erickson and Artin Massihi did but unfortunately their videos explaining their side of the story were conveniently removed from places your YouTube -- while conveniently leaving the videos remaining to hear the kind of stories you heard.


Step back a moment and ask yourself,

“How exactly would Dr Dan Erickson know if someone else’s patient said this?”

There was massive regional differences in how different parts of the country and even different parts of the same state responded to COVID.


Was this a yes or a no?


The issue was their extrapolation of their local keyhole perception to the entire country.

Flawed in many ways: https://www.acep.org/corona/COVID-19-alert/covid-19-articles...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: