Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Good old HN. It's so easy to predict what will happen to a comment like this - in this case, +1 because it's mildly witty compared to the other comments, -1 because someone feels like it shouldn't be upvoted, and another -1 because it's at the bottom or is now relatively content-free compared to the newer posts. Will probably settle around 0 or -1, depending on how long the post stays on the front page. I'd gladly take the two-point hit in order to verify my suspicions.


http://www.cracked.com/funny-3809-internet-argument-techniqu...

I'll probably get more downvotes than you for this, and maybe even a "this belongs in Reddit" type comment, but you're obviously trying to pull "Winning by losing" on us. Besides, it's not a "prediction" if you say it after the event.

p.s. Your original comment was not very witty. :p


Ah, my prediction was wrong. But little do you know that I predicted that my prediction would be wrong because I knew that by openly anticipating my comment's downvoting, I would prompt you to upvote it. Dance, puppets, dance! How droll. Now excuse me while I go stroke my white Persian. Mmm... exquisite...


It's not a prediction. I tracked the comment throughout the day. Hence the description of the movement.


Don't worry. I bet there are lots of HN'ers who regularly experiment and A/B test HN comments & submissions, in order to learn what yields the best karma. A bit like SEO but just for HN.


If someone is actually doing this, I'd love to see a writeup. Never underestimate other ocd nerds :)


I tried doing some testing a while back but PG didn't appreciate it.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: