HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
NY’s “Amazon Tax” Takes First Casualty: Overstock Affiliates (techcrunch.com)
17 points by kyro on May 14, 2008 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments


switches LinkShare address to Chicago from NYC & reapplies


Hopefully as many online retailers as possible follow suit OR Amazon wins its suit. If that doesn't get NY to change its socialist ways, nothing will.

Edit: I do feel bad for the NY based affiliates who will be hurt in the short-term. Hopefully they RAGE at their respective government representatives.


So...by NY taxing people on stuff they are supposed to pay taxes on anyways, that makes them socialists? Interesting stance on the subject.


No, any marginal tax increase just makes them more socialist leaning than they already are. In addition to state and federal income taxes, NYC residents (where about half of New Yorkers live), have to pay local income taxes as well as property and sales taxes.

For many residents (not just rich people), taxes hover around 40%, which is beyond ridiculous. Heck, paying taxes over 20% is infuriating enough. People complain about jobs being outsourced and companies closing down...a great way to fix this is to lower taxes and get rid of all the pet projects, red tape and blatant inefficiencies that plague our government and leech on our workers' earned dollars.

Ok - I'm done ranting; big government needs to go away.


The whole idea of having a union of states was that the states can compete with each other, If New York makes it hard enough to do business there, business will be done elsewhere. (See: Delaware, Nevada, Wyoming)

What should be happening is that NY has just made it undesirable to do business there. There should soon be a list of companies that just won't sell there as it is too much hassle. This is probably the goal. In some politicians muddled thinking this will help local businesses... Protectionism is ugly, even when states do it.


Taxing people is fine, bending the laws to impose restrictions on out of state merchants is not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: