Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So, whether they'd work on making surveillance for totalitarian states was based on whether they'd make $60/k year or $100/k, and afford stuff "nice vacation" for the kids?

Doesn't sound like a principled stance.

Basically it rounds down to: they would consider a more ethical job, but it's their last priority, well behind a good salary and nice benefits...

(It's understandable of course, just not principled)



Isn't that fairly rational? The difference between $100k a year and $60k a year is enormous.


In the sense of self-benefit, yes, it's rational.

>The difference between $100k a year and $60k a year is enormous.

Principles shouldn't depend on that though. Else "Yeah, I'd help kill kids and kittens for $1m" would also be an acceptable answer. $1m is also enormous compared to $100k.

Decent people have made much bigger sacrifices that living with $60K a year for doing the right thing...


Principles don't depend on that, but house prices do and if you know the house market in Germany then you'd get it.


I doubt anybody who is not a programmer making over 60K is homeless in Germany...


I wish, world would be black and white. And job market would be fair with unlimited opportunities everywhere.


>I wish, world would be black and white

Doesn't have to be black and white. In fact, it's anything but. You can get a lesser job, with, as you said, 60K instead of $100K, and still take the principled stance. Black and white would be more like having to either work for the surveillance company selling to authoritarian regimes, or starving.

Losing your perks is not a "black or white" ethical choice.

>And job market would be fair with unlimited opportunities everywhere.

If they can only be good if they have nothing to give up for choosing so, and only when there are "unlimited opportunities" to ensure that choosing the more ethical job doesn't hurt their salary at all, then they shouldn't bother...




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: