re #2: on the subject of 'correct' results. if I search for 'cat' whos to say what's 'correct' maybe i was looking for lol cat images, in which case returning information about care and feeding of a pet cat would be wrong. way too subjective.
also re#4, i'm a 'bad guy' i DEPEND on a stream of traffic from google to hack my victims computers so they join my botnet. how dare google shut me down! or: i'm a content farm with content so low quality no one stays on the page longer than 0:01. yet that nets me ad revenues, so i depend on traffic from google! how dare they shut me down even though my page is useless to searchers.
also re#4, i'm a 'bad guy' i DEPEND on a stream of traffic from google to hack my victims computers so they join my botnet. how dare google shut me down! or: i'm a content farm with content so low quality no one stays on the page longer than 0:01. yet that nets me ad revenues, so i depend on traffic from google! how dare they shut me down even though my page is useless to searchers.