The answers you are looking for have been posted a million other times in response to a million other questions by millions of other people. To claim that silence on your particular question means there are no answers or that you are correct is disingenuous.
My objection is not to asking questions or wanting discussion. It's the implication that because people didn't respond to his specific set of questions (which weren't unique and were echoed/responded to many other places on the same page) means there weren't good answers and that his speculative position had merit.
We know this, so we downvote.