Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> China is way more innovative than much of Europe for example

Of course they are, having built upon stolen EU and US tech and having trained their people in the West. But they learn fast and incrementally improve those designs. The difference is the Russians had their very own designs. Even in electronics, their concepts are fundamentally different from western concepts.



  > having built upon stolen EU and US tech and trained their people in the West. But they learn fast and incrementally improved those designs.
its the way for many successful countries... the u.s stole tech and ignored patents from england/europe to a great result, same with korea and japan and taiwan (with regard to "the west") etc... its not unusual


Yea this is true, it’s just annoying that they do that and then boast as if it’s their own technology while screaming about the virtues of their State, which, is inarguably inferior on this particular point given that in order to advance in technology they must acquire it from superior economic systems.


Of course, all innovation is built on copying and improving others' ideas. Calling this "theft" is as absurd as saying that the Greeks "stole" mathematics from Ancient Egypt, or that Renaissance Europe "stole" natural philosophy from the Islamic world (who in turn "stole" it from the Greeks etc).


Greeks came up with logical proofs for their claims. That's what defines mathematics. Ancient Egyptians didn't have those.


Who is paying the royalty for gun powder?


Uh, this is disingenuous. Patents are limited to 20 years, and for a good reason.

(I would wish for much shorter copyrights, too, or at least for the need to register and pay them after X years.)


You are missing the point.

In the era there is no royalty system at all. The moment royalty was introduced, it was unfair, unequal, already with a clear economy and political agenda.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: