Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Obviously people have guard dogs to guard things.

But dangerous dogs who attack strangers don’t ask questions. If they’ll bite a strange thief, they’ll bite other strangers without bad motives. Dogs are smart, but they don’t understand “Hi I’m your new mailman”, etc.



Yeah some little kid wanders into the wrong space, shouldn't result in a dog attack.


By this logic nobody should be allowed to own a pool. Instead we require pools to be fenced, which is the same thing people do with guard dogs.


Pools don't jump over fences, though.


In what reality are kids inadvertently wandering into junkyards and getting harmed by junkyard dogs in large numbers?


Kids were brought up as the reason that pools are fenced. Because adults tend to have motor controls and an understanding of their ability to swim, so pools aren't usually a danger to adults.

By contrast, people of all ages can be bitten by vicious dogs ... and shouldn't be. Yet, they are, in large numbers.

Dogs go to the vet. Dogs jump over fences, they run out open gates. People go to junkyards. There are many opportunities for a junkyard dog to interact with people it shouldn't bite.


That does sound serious. I wonder if there are any anti junkyard dog grassroots movements that one could join to help put an end to this madness?



But kids do.


No, the small children who are at risk for falling into a pool do not jump fences.

Regardless, if your pool had a history of safety issues, you should be expecting attention from regulators and insurers. Query your favorite search engine for "pool closed following death"


Mailboxes are typically outside of the fenced area where the dog is. Stay off my property and you won't have issues, is the point.


> Mailboxes are typically outside of the fenced area where the dog is. Stay off my property and you won't have issues, is the point.

They typically are, yet mail delivery personnel are attacked by dogs constantly.

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/us-postal-service-r...


That was just one example of many plausible scenarios. There are dozens of scenarios where dogs and people may be on different sides of said fence. The issue is an indiscriminate danger to people. It's the same reason you can't booby trap your own property.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: