Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Where have you been? I think you may be uninformed on this.

Here's some details: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/26/technology/twitter-musk-b.... Later when Elon sought to pull out of the deal, Twitter threatened to go to court to enforce that $1B fee, which led to the buyout proceeding.



> Where have you been? I think you may be uninformed on this.

I think you are victim to reading headlines and not understanding what Twitter went to court over. Elon paying the $1B wouldn’t have gotten him out of having to complete the deal.

Here’s some details: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/05/13/elon-musk-cant-just-walk-awa...


I was aware that Twitter went to court to complete the deal, but I admit to being misinformed as much of the analysis I read stated both avenues ($1B fee or force the acquisition) were viable.

For example, Dan Ives, who is often quoted in articles about this deal, had this to tweet: https://twitter.com/DivesTech/status/1545527442491822089?s=2...

It appears that is incorrect.


> I admit to being misinformed

Thank you for replying earnestly and humbly. I wish more did that!


As per your own link, the situations where that deal could be broken and the fee would be applicable were very limited (Musk not getting financing, Twitter finding a higher bidder). Musk changing his mind was not one of those situations, it was a binding deal.

Twitter did not sue for the $1b, but for specific perfomance, i.e. closing the deal.


Fair enough, I'm not versed on the legal in's and out's and it appears you're correct.

I knew Twitter sought to close the deal, but most of the analysis I read claimed they could have chosen the $1B instead, as if both were viable legal paths. It appears that is incorrect.


The $1b fine was not available to just use to back out of the deal. You are misinformed on this.


I agree, I was misinformed. Too many articles state both acquisition or $1B fine were viable routes for Twitter, but other sources with more solid analysis look to contradict that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: