Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes! It's debatable current models demonstrate any kind of "intelligence", but AGI is so far off it's ridiculous to even mention it. But not everyone's delusional. Here's what Yann Le Cun is currently saying:

> It seems to me that before "urgently figuring out how to control AI systems much smarter than us" we need to have the beginning of a hint of a design for a system smarter than a house cat.

and

> don't confuse the superhuman knowledge accumulation and retrieval abilities of current LLMs with actual intelligence

https://x.com/ylecun/status/1791890883425570823



Okay, so describe to me when and how we’ll detect and mitigate problems as we approach AGI or superintelligence.

The promise of upside grows exactly in lockstep with the danger of downside.

It is absolutely rational to say: “if our AI safety research lab is being hijacked by commercial interests before it’s even commercially viable as a business, then how will we possibly pull the plug on the final descent?”

P.S. neither Yann nor me nor you nor Sam nor Greg know what “real intelligence” is, and we certainly don’t know what superhuman intelligence is just the same way an ant couldn’t possibly know what human intelligence is. It is inconceivable to us — that is the point of intelligence.


We're about as close to AGI as we are to developing superluminal space flight and working time machines.


Umm, no. We can point to concrete mathematical and empirical evidence of those two things being impossible.

Point to the physical laws that indicate AGI or superintelligence is impossible or even maybe-impossible. No such laws exist.


[flagged]


Is this HN-quality commentary?


Well, flagging it didn't do any good, so evidently the admins believe it is.


So Le Cun's house cat can write Python code, author musical compositions, and create detailed artwork.

I would like to buy Yann's house cat, please. It will get along well with the rather impressive stochastic parrot I bought from someone else on HN.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: