Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>How would you feel if you were one of them?

>I'd feel pretty upset.

Agreed.

Yes, flying in space is cool. No, most people don't want to do this indefinitely. Astronauts retire all the time even when they are 100% guaranteed more flight time if they didn't retire; a whole bunch did that in the 1960s and 1970s (some, like Frank Borman, 100% guaranteed to walk on the moon), and more during the shuttle era.

It's one thing to have a mission extended by a day, as happened to the shuttle routinely because of bad weather at the landing site. Skylab 4's mission I believe got extended by 28 days, but that was a known possibility before launch. To have an eight-day mission be possibly extended to eight months is in no way shape or form OK.



Would you prefer 8 months and a safe ride down on a Dragon, or 8 days and taking your chances on the Starliner?

Not a rhetorical question, since you can argue both sides of the case. Even floating around in space for 8 months is not risk free.


>Even floating around in space for 8 months is not risk free.

Correct. That said, ISS's quarter century of operations is a pretty good track record. Starliner's so far is dismal.

The best solution is to bring Wilmore and Williams back sooner than February. If that means Boeing paying for a rescue Crew Dragon launch, so be it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: