Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The S in MCP stands for security.


And the D in AI stands for design.


I'm not sure I get this one.


There's no 'D' IN 'AI' and no 'S' in 'MCP'. I take it to mean no one is designing AI and MCP isn't secure.


More specifically, the neural network itself is never designed, only evolved/trained. Hence, unexpected behavior that no human intentionally added.


Neural networks absolutely are designed. Network architecture is one of the primary innovations in NNs over the years, and transformer architectures are the biggest development that enabled modern LLMs.

In addition, behavior is designed indirectly through human reinforcement.

The individual weights aren’t designed themselves, but there is a ton of design that goes into neural networks.


I'm admittedly out of my depth, but think the point is the current state of architecture is one of rapid and volatile iteration. There isn't really a comprehensive "design" because each generation is building (and in some cases rebuilding) upon the previous generation.


Aren't networks designed, only weights evolved?


As someone who has designed neural network architectures, I disagree.


Thanks, we're now 1 week away from the SMCP protocol.


MCPS://


In the spirit of FTP, both SMCP and MCPS, and they'll probably both be insecure.


The P in WFH stands for productive.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: