Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From year to year more politics and less interesting stuff.


Hacking and politics was always deeply intertwined in Germany/Europe. Especially the CCC has always been at least as much a political organization as it is a hacker community.


Hey, at least you can reasonably argue that the political content has been headed downhill since the more aggressive days of the past. Do we see wikileaks or the likes anymore? Not really.

Without direct action it's just nerds reading out their blog posts about politics, which couldn't be less interesting.


There has been plenty of direct action in recent years, but I can't really think of any on a global scale. Lots of smaller things on a German level, like journalists reporting about infiltrating a Great Replacement conference hosted by the second biggest political party here.


Sure, but it is unarguably much more boring stuff than it was years ago. I attend almost every Congress with a variety of groups, and there's certainly been a culture shift over the years from lots of anarchists who had no qualms with breaking the law to much more corporate scaredy-cats.

Congress seems to keep growing so perhaps this is just serving a broader audience. But knowing a lot of long-time attendees, I'm certainly not alone in thinking Congress is starting to be less interesting than it used to be. I'm certainly not trying to say the event sucks though, there's still a plenty of interesting stuff happening.


Love that you complain about not enough people breaking the law and somewhere below complains about to many people breaking the law

Let's be real, the videos get far to much eyes to break the law. There are smaller talks and groups where it looks different.


Back in the old days, you could sit down at a table in the hackcenter and do stuff that was more of the exploratory pentesting kind. Because everyone around you understood. Because there were strict "no-photos" policies in place. Because all people were technical and in it primarily for the technical challenge.

Nowadays you cannot do that anymore, because most visitors are non-technical. Nobody respects the photo policy. Everyone judges your actions through their political lens. Instead all the "action" happens elsewhere and CCC became much more about social stuff, talking and politics. And of course about policing and judging other peoples' politics.


I'm not just referring to the talks, but the whole event. But we used to have groups like wikileaks heavily featured, they certainly weren't worried about too many eyeballs.


And we all know how that ended...


>like journalists reporting about infiltrating a Great Replacement conference hosted by the second biggest political party here.

And making stuff up that was never talked about there to start a political movement to get that party banned? Yeah nice democracy and journalism there.


Were you at this conference?


You can ask the court that forbid repeating this made-up stuff ;)


Actually I can't ask a court whether you were at that conference without knowing your legal identity - care to share? And why should I expect the court to have a complete list of who was there, and to answer questions about that list? Seems much easier to ask you, and it's strange you don't want to answer.


What are you talking about? Pure nonsense. Discussions about "great replacement" never happened, that's an undeniable fact proven by court records and news media are not allowed to repeat these claims (324 O 439/24, 324 O 524/24, 7 W 78/24).


You might want to check your own source there. Seems to be the opposite of what you claim. The complaints were dismissed and the media is allowed to report.

https://rsw.beck.de/aktuell/daily/meldung/detail/lg-hamburg-...

But what does this have to do with your suggestion that I should ask the court whether you were at the meeting?


You might want to read the post again, the court claimed it not as a journalistic news article but as an opinion piece. And it's not the final verdict.

>whether you were at the meeting?

Where you? You are clearly missing the point.


again this myth. look at past fahrplans, there was always quite some political stuff. you just agreed with it and therefore it was not inconvenient.


In terms of the extent, no.


So you did a comparative analysis of previous events and there's no indication that there's more politics?


The user had more arguments than just "it's all politics". What level of scrutiny does his statement have to hold up to? Because as far as I am concerned this is not here to find scientific truths.


I don't know man. It's always the same debate: It's either "too much politics" or "no change at all" whenever this issue comes up and the "nothing changed" crowd keeps on reminding everyone that C3 "was always like that". I'm not requesting a scientific study but if you're this convinced that nothing changed despite may old school attendees chiming in to confirm the opposite, perhaps it would be helpful to compare old and new schedules.


I find it strange you didn't latch on to the original comment, which has the exact same problem you complained about, but reacted to the response. The best action is to ignore threads and sub-threads you don't care about and leave others who do to their fun.


CCC was always political (very left to far left). Never understood why hacking has to be political in the first place.


well, it has a lot to do with people growing up during cold war and german reunification.

There were many stories where people lost faith in politics (e.g. after Chernobyl), so people gathered together to do stuff on their own. I think being "social" (to all people), decentralized and mistrusting authorities is just a left thing. so that's just a natural thing imho


That chernobyl and western politics is in any way connected is due to decades unscientific fearmongering. And Berlin has always been a hotbed for that.

But chernybyl isnt the only or primary reason.


Interesting, the same came to my mind when reading the fahrplan.


read up on the history of the CCC, it might blow your mind


People come for the technical talks and leave for for the politics.

Every year you got new people who find out the hard way that the CCC is a place for ardent activism, not for critical thinking.

The people who stay do it to meet their friends there.


Not true, better line up than ted AI or Next


Hard to ignore in these times...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: