Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> You took away the wrong thing

I'm more willing to believe they were taught the wrong thing.



If you're going to wrote a blog post on the topic, probably worth spending a few minutes double checking your understanding of the "thing". I don't doubt that the author may have been taught the wrong thing, but to write an entire post starting from and remaining in a state of misunderstanding is not particularly useful.


The entire point of the article is that his original understanding of the “thing” was a misunderstanding, with a heavy emphasis on how his teachers led him to that misunderstanding.

Author used a rhetorical device that you seem to have missed.


The article brings with an incorrect premise, and then argues a different point.

The opening premise is: NP-hardness is easy in theory, hard in practice, the point made is that it’s easy in practice. But that premise is itself wrong: complexity theorists know that NP-hardness is in fact, hard in theory.


No doubt.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: