Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The semantic diff is pretty cool. It will probably be pretty hard to apply that to C (cpp) and Lisp (macros, and especially the programmable readers in some Lisps). But maybe we don't actually need a solution for the general case and displaying "most" changes in a semantic way is enough.

I imagine these higher-level diffs could be especially useful for things where one doesn't have that much insight into the source code - for example, scanning for API changes between two versions of a Framework (where maybe even displaying only changes to public methods/exports would be enough). In any case, diffs on the AST level seem like a good, and quite under-explored, idea.



> It will probably be pretty hard to apply that to C (cpp) and Lisp (macros, and especially the programmable readers in some Lisps).

C is really hard to parse because of preprocessor. We built a prototype parser for it, and it mostly works, but it's not ready yet for the prime time.

Lisp must be a much simpler language to parse, though.

> scanning for API changes between two versions of a framework

Yes, we have this idea on the to-do list! Imagine that you are comparing two different branches of development, or two different tagged releases, and see high-level API changes between them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: