HN2new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thank you. If it's SFTP, then it's a different beast and that changaes a lot.

Yes, I know the difference between FTP and SFTP. In this case the technical details are important: SFTP is effectively a bolt-on file transfer protocol which requires an already established (authenticated) connection. It is most easily used with SSH, but as far as I recall, it could be implemented to work from any protocol that has the concept of a session. (And if my memory serves me right, SILC implemented it as a logical replacement for DCC.)

The other security measures you list also make me feel better. From other posters I have already learned that NACHA transfers have an integrity check file which may be, in some systems, ignored. If the files are indeed PGP encrypted, then that may be less of an issue. The message integrity checks in PGP are certainly robust. :) [Corruption-in-transit becomes a moot point, and the same applies for route hijacking.]

I give you wholehearted thanks, and want to offer an apology for my earlier tone. However, I still have a reason to cringe.

Just let me cringe at the article author instead.



I realize the article didn't say SFTP, but that couldn't be gathered from "secure FTP," as that's precisely what SFTP means?


SFTP is SSH File Transfer Protocol, and is actually its own protocol (not FTP over SSH).

There's also FTPS, which is FTP with TLS. That's closer to "secure FTP," but as @segmondy pointed out, this isn't what they use.

When I read it I thought the author was claiming plain FTP was secure too.


I understand the difference, yet the term "Secure FTP" is most often used to refer to SFTP and not FTPS, in my experience.

From wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_Transfer_Protocol#Secure_F...) "The SSH file transfer protocol or secure FTP (SFTP)..."

Multiple google searches also yielded similar language.


All of the banks I deal with use FTPS (which is called "secure" ftp). I have yet to deal with one that uses SFTP (ssh-ftp).

http://www.differencebetween.net/technology/internet/differe...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: